Comparison of different methods of obtaining a resilient organic matter fraction in Alpine soils

Soil organic matter (SOM) may give precious information about the age of soil landscapes and, thus, can contribute to decipher geomorphic surface dynamics. We tested five methods to isolate the oldest possible stable organic matter of 2 soil profiles developed on a Pleistocene morainic paragneiss substratum in an Alpine environment in northern Italy. Before and after the individual treatments, the organic fraction was dated with C. The first two methods consist in the oxidation of organic matter with 10% hypochlorite (NaOCl), followed by dissolution of minerals with 10% hydrofluoric acid (HF) or 1M Aqua Regia. Methods 3 and 4 were similar to the first two but with a changed order of the treatments (chemical oxidation as the last step). Method 5 included only a treatment with hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) for 7 days. Methods 1 to 4 enabled, in theory, the separation of labile, mineral-protected and recalcitrant SOM fractions. With method 5 only two different fractions can be discerned, i.e. a labile one and a stable one. The lowest ages for each soil were obtained with methods 1 to 3 (5176 and 8835 cal BP). Higher ages were obtained with method 4 (Aqua Regia and NaOCl). In general, methods 1 4 showed increasing ages with increasing soil depth. The H2O2 treatment, however, left behind an organic fraction with the highest ages of up to 17000 cal BP in the topsoil and decreasing ages with soil depth. In general, the C ages of the treatment-resistant fraction increased in the order: untreated samples < method 3 (HF + NaOCl) ≤ method 1 (NaOCl + HF) ≈ method 2 (NaOCl + Aqua Regia) < method 4 (Aqua Regia + NaOCl) < method 5 (H2O2). Before and after the individual treatments, the fractions were analysed for their C and N content, functional groups were measured with FT-IR and complementary information was obtained with SEM-EDS. The changes in functional groups before and after the treatment with methods 1 and 3 were not very distinct. NaOCl was a too weak reagent to oxidise all labile organic matter in soils. It seems to work more or less properly only in soils with a low OC content. The use of HF produced artefacts such as the precipitation of cryolite. This could also influence organic matter (co-precipitation) and finally its age. HF treatment destroyed kaolinite, attacked quartz but did not affect that much other phyllosilicates like mica. The subdivision of OM into a labile, mineral-protected and recalcitrant fraction using NaOCl and HF was consequently far from being precise. Consequently, these methods might be questioned. About 90% of organic C was oxidised with H2O2 (method 5) but only 60% of N removed. The remaining organic matter was enriched in nitrogen with a C/N ratio between 3 to 10, aliphatic, aromatic and amide compounds. H2O2 isolated the oldest and most stable OM pool. Our results indicate that the isolated organic matter after the H2O2 treatment can probably be used to estimate the age of the earliest formation of Holocene/Pleistocene-aged Alpine soils. The obtained ages corresponded well with the maximum age of charcoal fragments and the geomorphological settings in particular the end of the Egesenequivalent glacial state and the oldest Dryas.